Prospect Sierra Eighth Graders discuss and debate Kekla Magoon's groundbreaking novel
Thursday, January 27, 2011
I think that Sam didn't want to get his brother into more trouble so he hid the gun. I agree with this action because I think Sam's father would have done something radical about it and Sam would be in trouble with Stick, his brother, who he looks up to. I think that Sam should not go forward with the Black Panther nonsense. I think to someone of the African American race, living in that time, would think that the Black Panthers hold an appealing image and that they portray themselves as heroes. In stories the hero always has to kill or, for the younger children, "defeat" the villain, i think that kids will see them as more of a hero who has to kill a lot of villains as opposed to a villain who is killing people. I think Sam should get out of his involvement with the Black Panthers but i would understand how it might seem like a more appealing offer than just holding demonstrations and peacefully putting a stop to the discrimination which could take a very, very long time. It might seem like since the Black Panthers way is faster it is the better decision...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I must disagree with you about hiding the gun. What if Stick ACTUALLY found it? A life- however racist that person may be- is endangered. Also, I think that Sam and Stick's father would prefer finding out about the gun BEFORE somebody is hurt, rather than after. I realize of course that you are against the Black Panthers as well, but I think that, just to be safe/safer, Sam should just dispose of the gun entirely. Stick needs to realize that a gun is a powerful object that should never be in the hands of someone ready, willing, and able to use it.
ReplyDelete